I use www.commonsensemedia.org, but I'm wondering if there are other resources as well... I've found that often the MPAA rating on a film is wrong, or doesn't provide me enough information. For instance, I wanted to know if my 13yo should watch Precious (IMDB said 13+) but when I checked Common Sense Media, they said 17+!

Confused...

asked 09 Jan '10, 16:14

YMCbuzz's gravatar image

YMCbuzz
2.1k51225
accept rate: 12%


For movies, Focus on the Family runs a website called Plugged In Online. I don't always agree with their ratings on "family friendliness" because they are incredibly conservative. But they are very detailed about what to expect in the movie in terms of language, sex, violence, etc.

As for books and tv shows, my mom always took an interest in what I was reading and watching. It was not unusual for her to come in and watch a few episodes of whatever series I was into at the time. With the books I got from the library, if she was unfamiliar with the author, she would wait until I set it down and read the summary on the back, or flat out ask me what the book was about. At that time, the internet was still developing, but there are a lot of resources out there now that were not available when I was growing up. You can try googling the book or the tv show to see what reviews are available about them, or you can also try reading the reviews on Netflix and Amazon.

link

answered 09 Jan '10, 16:37

mkcoehoorn's gravatar image

mkcoehoorn
8.2k12348
accept rate: 8%

1

+1 for your mom taking the time out to sample your viewing/reading. i hope i will do the same too when the time comes

(10 Jan '10, 00:11) Lin

I'm partially repeating info I posted in a previous question:

Here are some web sites that specialize in media reviews with respect to what's appropriate for kids:

There are a variety of other ways you can find out about media (particularly movies) without having to see the whole film first. Here are some tips:

  • Watch the trailer online -- this 2 minute investment can give you a pretty good idea if it will be scary, violent, or sexy (because those movies want to make it very clear from the trailers that it contains such things, to get people to see it).
  • Use IMDB to look up the film and see what other work the director and writers have done -- maybe they are things you've seen and liked (or not), and you can read the comments and reviews about those previous movies from the same creators.
  • Look in a newspaper (or its web site) -- major papers almost always have reviews when a movie opens that not only discuss the film in detail, but also generally point out which bits might be an issue for kids.
  • There are TV shows that review movies, for example in the US there is a popular show "At The Movies" (a long time ago, it was hosted by Siskel and Ebert, but now it's a different set of reviewers). You don't have to agree with their reviews, but just listening to them talk about movies for a couple minutes can give you a good idea about what to expect from each one.
  • You may disagree with MPAA ratings (I think they are too permissive with violence and gore, too restrictive with fairly tame nudity and sexuality), but they are relatively consistent. Considering a PG-13 movie? It'll probably have a bunch of people die and more swear words than you expect from a kid's movie. Don't be surprised, it's meant for teenagers.

Finally, resist the temptation to see things the weekend they open. By the second week, the "buzz" will be well established about what the films really are (not just the pre-release messaging the marketers wanted you to hear) and you can make a better judgment. Maybe even somebody else you know has seen it and can tell you about it.

link

answered 09 Jan '10, 19:30

lgritz's gravatar image

lgritz
6.1k1419
accept rate: 14%

Dove.org is a good one -- not only does it tell you THEIR recommendations (which are conservative and more cautious than I usually am) but they also tell you WHY they rated each movie the way they did. For example: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1:

"Content Description: Sex: A comment about mating; a potion makes a girl look like a male wearing a bra; a couple share a kiss; a woman passionately kisses a man she thinks is her husband but he isn't; a nude couple obscured by clouds kiss; a male villain gets in a girl's face in a sexually intimidating way. Language: H-3; D-1; A-1; OMG-2: P-1 Violence: A woman falls hard on table and dies; many uses of wands and many characters are zapped with them; evil creatures attack; bloody wound seen on character's neck and on a character's shoulder and it is graphic; characters are grabbed and shoved and a couple of characters are shoved to the floor; character stabbed with wand though the impact is not seen; small explosions; large snake attacks a character; character is stabbed; a character is seen hanging but it is a shadow and animated and very brief; a character's hair is grabbed; character is stabbed and blood is seen on knife. Drugs: Drinks are seen at a wedding reception but what they are is not clear. Nudity: Cleavage; shirtless males; bra seen on male; nude couple embrace but are obscured by clouds. Other: A few jump scenes including a giant snake in a scene; the use of magic and evil powers as wands are used to zap characters and there are some deaths; riding on brooms; a mention of the school of witches and wizards; a character mentions having put curses on a character; an evil and controlling group; man steals wand from dead corps; the subject of death."

See? I like the details because then I can come to my own conclusions about what my son is able to see.

They can be a little Bible-thumpy, but I've found their ratings to be honest and accurate.

Hope this helps!

link

answered 18 May '11, 21:36

Cheryllion's gravatar image

Cheryllion
211
accept rate: 0%

edited 18 May '11, 23:22

Tammy's gravatar image

Tammy ♦♦
7.6k22539

Your answer
toggle preview

Follow this question

By Email:

Once you sign in you will be able to subscribe for any updates here

By RSS:

Answers

Answers and Comments

Markdown Basics

  • *italic* or _italic_
  • **bold** or __bold__
  • link:[text](http://url.com/ "Title")
  • image?![alt text](/path/img.jpg "Title")
  • numbered list: 1. Foo 2. Bar
  • to add a line break simply add two spaces to where you would like the new line to be.
  • basic HTML tags are also supported

Tags:

×24
×7

Asked: 09 Jan '10, 16:14

Seen: 7,566 times

Last updated: 18 May '11, 23:23