vote up 8 vote down
star
2

I've heard this time and time again, but is it a wives tale?

flag
+1 This was something I had also wondered! – Emi Jan 30 at 8:27

3 Answers

vote up 9 vote down

It is partly true.

All babies have a reflex that makes them stop breathing for a short while. This reflex is triggered when the face is put underwater, as well as when you blow a gust of air in his or her face. You yourself can feel the remainders of this reflex if you try to breathe with a strong wind in your face.

This does not mean that babies can swim.

Triggering this reflex is not very comfortable for the babies, because they can't breathe for one or two seconds even when they are out of the water again.

Source: We just finished a baby swimming course, where the toddlers are accustomed to the water and to being underwater without triggering this reflex and without drowning. I can highly recommend such a course.

link|flag
+1 Great explanation. – Emi Jan 30 at 8:28
Wow, thanks, I had no idea that was a reflex -- thanks for the interesting point about how we can still feel it when a wind blows in our face! – Anne Jan 31 at 13:29
vote up 3 vote down

Good question, I was wondering that, too.

When I looked this up I found an interesting piece of advice / warning from babycenter.com: "Don't put a baby less than 6 months old under the water. Although infants naturally hold their breath under water, they continue to swallow."

link|flag
+1 important warning; I had missed that. – brandstaetter Feb 5 at 13:32
vote up 0 vote down

We wanted to get our daughter into the water early to preserve her water instinct.

We started her on swimming lessons at 3 months old. Whenever we put her under the water it was only a brief dunking (about as long as her reflex lasts - say around half a second). She got used to it fairly quickly and only complained when she got tired of it (after 6 or 7 dunks over a half hour).

We won't think of putting her underwater for longer than that until she can hold her breath on command.

I've never heard about the supposed ability to swim, though. That seems rather ridiculous, given their lack of strength and motor control.

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.